The Sunday Teardown · Apples
Everything about an apple is managed except its price. A patent decides who may plant the tree, and a trademark decides what the fruit may be called. Neither kept the price of Cosmic Crisp from falling by more than half.
Two apples sit a few feet apart in the produce department. One is Honeycrisp, which anyone in the country may plant. The other is Cosmic Crisp, which is patented and trademarked, and in North America only growers in Washington state may plant it. This week a Honeycrisp cost $0.89 at one supermarket chain and $1.32 at another. A Cosmic Crisp cost $1.35 at the first and $1.17 at the second, where it was organic.
Having an owner has not held the price of Cosmic Crisp up. In its first season, 2019-20, a 40 pound box averaged $72.80 at the shipping point, which is the price a packer charges as the box leaves the warehouse. By late 2024 it was just over $28. Honeycrisp has been off patent since 2008, and it still brings the highest price of the 7 varieties on this week’s USDA shipping-point report from Washington.
This week’s teardown is the apple, and it comes in 3 parts. The first is who owns an apple and who gets paid, laid out in one place. The second is how an apple is stored for up to a year and run through a packing line, which is my side of the food business. The third is the money. They add up to one conclusion. Ownership decides who may grow an apple and what it may be called. Supply and cost decide what it sells for.
What the sticker says
The sticker is the only label a loose apple has, so it is the place to start. The 4 or 5 digit number on it is a price look-up code, or PLU, and the cashier uses it to ring up the right price. A 5 digit code that begins with 9 marks organic fruit. The codes come from an international produce trade federation, and no government agency requires them.
The code list also shows that a newer apple has 2 names. A large Honeycrisp is 3283 and a large Gala is 4135, and Honeycrisp and Gala are the names of the varieties. Cosmic Crisp is 3507, and the list files that code under WA 38. WA 38 is the variety. It is the name Washington State University’s breeding program gave the tree, and it is the name on the plant patent. Cosmic Crisp is a brand name that the university registered as a trademark. So the tree in the orchard is a WA 38, and the apple in the store is a Cosmic Crisp only because the people who grew and packed it were licensed to use the name.
Who owns what, and who gets paid
The 2 names are owned in 2 different ways, and that is the reason a newer apple has both. The variety is protected by a plant patent. A plant patent lasts 20 years from the day it is filed, and while it runs the owner can stop anyone else from propagating or selling the tree. When it ends, the variety belongs to the public. The brand name is protected by a trademark, which lasts for as long as the owner keeps using and renewing it. The patent on WA 38 is expected to expire in 2032. The Cosmic Crisp trademark can be kept for as long as the university uses and renews it.
Follow the chain for Cosmic Crisp from the top. Washington State University bred the apple, a cross of Enterprise and Honeycrisp, and it holds both the patent and the trademark. It hired a company called Proprietary Variety Management to run the licensing. That company licenses the nurseries that propagate the trees, the growers who plant them, and the packers and marketers who sell the fruit. It doesn’t sell fruit. In North America the only growers who can get a license are in Washington state. This April the university extended that exclusive right through May 26, 2032, the day the patent is expected to expire.
The money runs the other way. A grower pays $1 for each tree, and then 4.75% of sales on every box that sells above $20. On a $35 box that is $1.66, or 4.2 cents a pound. By late 2024 the tree and box royalties together had brought the university about $28 million.
The owner of the name also controls the launch. The first 300,000 trees were allocated by drawing, after growers had asked for about 4 million. Each fall the crop is picked in September and October and held in storage until a release date the brand sets, which was November 25 for the 2024 crop. In 2019 the university approved $10.1 million from its royalties to market the apple over 4 years. An apple with a release date and a marketing budget of that size had a better launch plan than most packaged foods get.
When the patent expires, which is expected in 2032, anyone may plant WA 38. The university has said it will still control who may sell the fruit as Cosmic Crisp. After that the tree will be public and the name will still be licensed.
Honeycrisp showed the industry why that difference matters. The University of Minnesota filed for its patent in 1988 and released the apple in 1991. It collected a royalty of $1.30 on each tree, which had come to more than $6 million by 2007. Then the patent expired, on November 7, 2008. Honeycrisp is the name of the variety, and since that day nobody in the United States has needed a license from the university to propagate it.
Universities released the apples that came next under tighter terms. The trade calls the arrangement a club, because only licensed growers may plant the tree. SweeTango, the brand name of a later Minnesota variety, was licensed to one company and grown through a cooperative that had about 45 growers in 2010. Pink Lady is an older example of the 2 names. The variety is Cripps Pink, anyone may sell it under that name, and a packer may put Pink Lady on the sticker only if the fruit meets the brand’s specifications.

What 4 apples cost this week
I priced 4 varieties at 2 supermarket chains this week. Both chains sell them by the apple, so the table does too.
Variety | Chain 1, each | Chain 2, each | The name on the sticker | Is the tree under patent? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Honeycrisp | $0.89 | $1.32 | The variety name | No. The patent expired in 2008 |
Cosmic Crisp | $1.35 | $1.17 (organic) | A trademark. The variety is WA 38 | Yes, until 2032 |
Gala | $0.75 | $0.82 | The variety name | No. It was patented in 1974 |
Red Delicious | $1.00 | Not carried | The variety name | No. The variety dates to the 1870s |
Regular shelf prices at 2 conventional supermarket chains, November 2026, excluding sale and warehouse-club prices. Whole apples are priced each. Newer strains of an older variety can be patented separately.
Read the prices against the last column. Cosmic Crisp, the only one of the 4 whose original tree is still under patent, was the most expensive apple at the first chain. At the second chain it was organic and still cost 15 cents less than the Honeycrisp. Honeycrisp, off patent since 2008, was the most expensive apple at the second chain and the second cheapest at the first, where it cost 11 cents less than a Red Delicious. The patent column doesn’t predict the price columns.
The question
If owning the name and the tree doesn't hold a price up, what does all of that management buy? Most of it buys time. An apple picked in October can be sold the following August still firm, and the methods behind that are the best part of this story.
Below the line for paid subscribers. I go through how a storage room holds an apple for up to 12 months, what the gas called 1-MCP does, and why organic packers can’t use it. I explain why Honeycrisp needs a different storage routine. Then I follow the packing line from the bin dump to the camera sorter and correct 2 common beliefs about the wax. I price whole apples against bagged slices and set this week’s shipping-point prices against what it costs to grow a box. I close with what I’m watching and what I’d buy.
Subscribe to Plant Floor to read the rest.
Become a paying subscriber of Plant Floor to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.
Read More NowAlready a subscriber? Sign in

